August 7, 2024

Types of Lidar Systems: Topographic vs. Bathymetric (Part 2 of 5)

Table of Contents

Introduction

Lidar technology comes in various forms, each tailored for specific applications. The two primary types are topographic and bathymetric Lidar. Understanding the differences between these systems is crucial for selecting the right tool for your research needs. Whether you're mapping rugged terrains or exploring underwater landscapes, knowing the capabilities and limitations of each type can make all the difference.

Topographic Lidar

  • Wavelengths Used: Typically operates in the near-infrared (NIR) spectrum (around 1064 nm).
  • Applications: Ideal for mapping land surfaces, including forests, urban areas, and infrastructure.
  • Limitations: Cannot penetrate water surfaces effectively due to high absorption and scattering of NIR wavelengths in water.
  • Example Models and Brands:
    • RIEGL VQ-1560 II: Known for high accuracy and dual-channel capabilities.
    • Leica ALS80: Offers high-density point clouds and rapid data acquisition.
  • Size and Weight: Generally compact and lightweight, suitable for mounting on drones, helicopters, and small aircraft.
  • Carrying Platforms: Can be carried by UAVs (Unmanned Aerial Vehicles), manned aircraft, and even ground vehicles for mobile mapping.

Bathymetric Lidar

  • Wavelengths Used: Uses green light (around 532 nm) which can penetrate water more effectively than NIR wavelengths.
  • Applications: Designed for measuring underwater topography, including coastal mapping, riverbed surveys, and underwater archaeology.
  • Limitations: Highly dependent on water clarity; effective up to 50 meters in clear water.
  • Example Models and Brands:
    • RIEGL VQ-840-G: High accuracy, capable of simultaneous topographic and bathymetric mapping.
    • Teledyne Optech CZMIL: Integrated topographic and bathymetric Lidar, high penetration depth.
  • Size and Weight: Typically larger and heavier than topographic Lidar systems due to the need for more powerful lasers and additional sensors.
  • Carrying Platforms: Usually mounted on manned aircraft or larger UAVs capable of carrying heavier payloads.

Comparative Analysis

  • Key Differences:
    • Wavelengths: NIR for topographic, green for bathymetric.
    • Penetration: Topographic Lidar is limited to land surfaces, while bathymetric Lidar can penetrate water.
  • Suitability for Various Tasks:
    • Topographic Lidar: Best for land-based applications.
    • Bathymetric Lidar: Essential for underwater and coastal studies.
  • Size and Weight Considerations:
    • Topographic Lidar: More versatile in terms of carrying platforms due to its compact size.
    • Bathymetric Lidar: Requires more robust platforms capable of handling larger and heavier equipment.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between topographic and bathymetric Lidar systems is essential for effective research and data collection. Each type has its unique strengths and limitations, making them suitable for different applications. By choosing the right Lidar system, researchers can achieve more accurate and comprehensive results in their studies. Whether you're mapping dense forests or exploring underwater landscapes, knowing the capabilities and limitations of each Lidar type will ensure you get the most out of this powerful technology.

Back to Home